Thursday, 2016-10-13

*** uck_ has joined #tacker00:14
*** uck has quit IRC00:14
*** uck_ has quit IRC00:15
*** bobh has quit IRC00:29
*** gongysh_ has joined #tacker00:36
*** bobmel has joined #tacker00:37
gongysh_sripriya, s3wong I have some python client patches needing review00:39
sripriyagongysh_: ack, can you please add me as a reviewer to the patches, will review it later tonight00:40
s3wonggongysh_: what is the link of the patch?00:42
*** bobmel has quit IRC00:42
s3wonggongysh_: (or as sripriya said, just add me to the reviewers list)00:42
aimeeuHi Tacker folks - I read that you are not attending the PTG but having your normal, virtual mid-cycle instead. When do you have your mid-cycle?00:48
gongysh_s3wong, sripriya I added your names in the reviewers list of my some tacker client patches. thanks00:51
sripriyaaimeeu: we plan to have the design meetup similar to midcyle format, we will have the pike design meetup around PTG timeframe00:52
aimeeusripriya: thanks! So no virtual meetup in February?00:52
sripriyawe ill have virtual meetup in february00:53
sripriyaaimeeu: ^00:53
sripriyaaimeeu: s/ill/will00:53
aimeeusripriya: Excellent - thanks for the info00:54
sripriyaaimeeu: sure, np00:54
sripriyagongysh_: ping00:59
gongysh_sripriya, hi01:00
sripriyagongysh_: are you by any chance aware of the recent dsvm failures seen on all patches01:00
sripriyagongysh_: one of them is here http://logs.openstack.org/35/379935/2/check/gate-tacker-dsvm-functional/d9dbc1c/logs/screen-h-eng.txt.gz?level=ERROR01:00
s3wongsripriya, gongysh_: seems like we aren't in sync with latest Heat?01:02
sripriyas3wong: it looks so, i was quickly looking into some of the recent patches that were merged in heat, and none of them raised a red flag, looks our dsvm failures started happening from couple of days back01:03
s3wongsripriya: hmm... what the heck is " create() takes at least 4 arguments (4 given)"01:06
s3wongat least 4 arguments and 4 are given... what's wrong? :-)01:07
sripriyas3wong: that refers to https://github.com/openstack/heat/blob/master/heat/engine/clients/os/keystone/heat_keystoneclient.py#L49501:08
gongysh_s3wong, it is also confusing me. at least 4, we give 4. seems good.01:08
sripriyas3wong: indeed weird01:08
gongysh_it seems it just failed the keypair tosca template. it is seemingly easy to reproduce01:10
s3wonggongysh_: need to fix ASAP, I suppose, to get gate working again...01:13
sripriyagongysh_: s3wong: raised a high priority bug to track this: https://bugs.launchpad.net/tacker/+bug/163290101:13
openstackLaunchpad bug 1632901 in tacker "tacker dsvm functional gate is breaking with heat server resource create error" [High,Confirmed]01:13
gongysh_I am setting up an env to reproduce it01:14
s3wonggongysh_: cool01:15
*** s3wong has quit IRC01:16
*** vishnoianil has quit IRC02:06
*** jaff_cheng has joined #tacker02:07
*** dkushwaha has joined #tacker02:38
*** bobmel has joined #tacker02:38
*** bobmel has quit IRC02:43
*** dkushwaha has quit IRC02:45
*** janki has joined #tacker03:22
*** dkushwaha has joined #tacker03:30
*** links has joined #tacker03:45
*** bobmel has joined #tacker04:39
*** gongysh_ has quit IRC04:43
*** bobmel has quit IRC04:43
*** bobmel has joined #tacker04:45
*** Vijayendra has joined #tacker04:46
*** bobmel has quit IRC04:49
*** diga has joined #tacker05:05
*** vishnoianil has joined #tacker05:21
*** neel has joined #tacker05:29
*** tbh has joined #tacker05:33
*** ramishra has joined #tacker06:10
*** Ravikiran_K has joined #tacker06:15
*** bobmel has joined #tacker06:15
*** vishwanathj is now known as vishwanathj_zzz06:16
*** bobmel has quit IRC06:20
*** ramishra_ has joined #tacker06:25
*** ramishra has quit IRC06:28
openstackgerritgongysh proposed openstack/python-tackerclient: make python34 CI job to pass  https://review.openstack.org/38549106:50
*** hparekh has joined #tacker07:05
*** bobmel has joined #tacker07:22
*** bobmel has quit IRC07:26
*** tbh has quit IRC07:42
*** neel has quit IRC08:40
*** ramishra_ has left #tacker08:53
*** janki has quit IRC09:17
*** Ravikiran_K has quit IRC09:17
*** diga has quit IRC09:17
*** hparekh has quit IRC09:17
*** tung_doan has quit IRC09:17
*** haiwei has quit IRC09:17
*** openstackgerrit has quit IRC09:17
*** dkushwaha has quit IRC09:17
*** vishwanathj_zzz has quit IRC09:17
*** bryan_att has quit IRC09:17
*** amit213 has quit IRC09:17
*** mbirru has quit IRC09:17
*** Qiming has quit IRC09:17
*** TonyXu has quit IRC09:17
*** sridhar_ram has quit IRC09:17
*** gongysh has quit IRC09:17
*** afranc has quit IRC09:17
*** jaff_cheng has quit IRC09:17
*** aimeeu has quit IRC09:17
*** igordcard has quit IRC09:22
*** bobmel has joined #tacker09:22
*** igordcard has joined #tacker09:22
*** bobmel has quit IRC09:27
*** amotoki has quit IRC10:01
*** janki has joined #tacker10:06
*** jaff_cheng has joined #tacker10:07
*** aimeeu has joined #tacker10:07
*** gongysh has joined #tacker10:09
*** afranc has joined #tacker10:09
*** gongysh has quit IRC10:10
*** afranc has quit IRC10:10
*** jaff_cheng has quit IRC10:10
*** aimeeu has quit IRC10:10
*** janki has quit IRC10:10
*** jaff_cheng has joined #tacker10:26
*** aimeeu has joined #tacker10:26
*** janki has joined #tacker10:27
*** diga has joined #tacker10:27
*** hparekh_ has joined #tacker10:27
*** Ravikiran_K has joined #tacker10:27
*** tung_doan has joined #tacker10:27
*** haiwei has joined #tacker10:27
*** gongysh has joined #tacker10:27
*** afranc has joined #tacker10:27
*** openstackgerrit has joined #tacker10:28
*** vishwanathj_zzz has joined #tacker10:28
*** bryan_att has joined #tacker10:28
*** amit213 has joined #tacker10:28
*** Qiming has joined #tacker10:28
*** TonyXu has joined #tacker10:28
*** sridhar_ram has joined #tacker10:28
*** aimeeu has quit IRC10:30
*** diga has quit IRC10:30
*** neel has joined #tacker10:33
*** amotoki has joined #tacker10:35
*** hparekh_ has quit IRC10:35
*** hparekh_ has joined #tacker10:35
*** links has quit IRC10:36
*** chenghang has joined #tacker10:44
*** aimeeu has joined #tacker10:44
*** chenghang has quit IRC10:44
*** jaff_cheng has quit IRC10:47
*** links has joined #tacker10:49
*** amotoki has quit IRC10:53
*** achatterjee has joined #tacker10:57
*** amotoki has joined #tacker11:00
openstackgerritvenkatamahesh proposed openstack/tacker: VNF event detail is modified to match with resource state  https://review.openstack.org/37993511:05
*** amotoki has quit IRC11:18
*** bobmel has joined #tacker11:23
*** Ravikiran_K has quit IRC11:24
*** bobmel has quit IRC11:28
*** diga has joined #tacker11:28
*** diga has quit IRC11:37
*** diga has joined #tacker11:38
*** neel has quit IRC11:45
*** bobh has joined #tacker11:59
*** hparekh_ has quit IRC12:12
*** bobmel has joined #tacker12:14
*** chenghang has joined #tacker12:21
*** chenghang is now known as jaff_cheng12:21
*** bobh has quit IRC12:29
*** lamt has joined #tacker12:59
*** lamt has quit IRC13:14
*** bobh has joined #tacker13:16
*** haiwei has quit IRC13:28
*** janki has quit IRC13:28
*** abinaya has joined #tacker13:35
*** links has quit IRC13:48
openstackgerritTung Doan proposed openstack/tacker: RFE: Alarm monitor  https://review.openstack.org/38247913:49
*** gongysh_ has joined #tacker14:13
gongysh_sripriya, don't forget to review some patches of python-tackerclient14:16
*** openstackgerrit has quit IRC14:18
*** openstackgerrit has joined #tacker14:19
*** gongysh_ has quit IRC14:33
*** tbh has joined #tacker14:36
*** lamt has joined #tacker14:39
*** tbh is now known as tbh_afk14:44
*** KanagarajM has joined #tacker14:58
*** bobh has quit IRC15:14
*** KanagarajM has quit IRC15:15
*** amotoki has joined #tacker15:32
*** amotoki has quit IRC15:40
*** jaff_cheng has quit IRC15:42
*** abinaya has quit IRC15:42
*** diga has quit IRC15:44
*** abinayav has joined #tacker15:47
*** vishwanathj_zzz is now known as vishwanathj15:48
*** abinayav has quit IRC15:52
*** amotoki has joined #tacker15:54
*** tbh_afk is now known as tbh15:55
*** abinaya has joined #tacker15:56
*** Vijayendra has quit IRC16:09
*** bobh has joined #tacker16:14
*** bobh has quit IRC16:19
*** Vijayendra has joined #tacker16:20
openstackgerritTung Doan proposed openstack/tacker: RFE: Alarm monitor  https://review.openstack.org/38247916:26
*** abinaya_ has joined #tacker16:44
*** abinaya has quit IRC16:45
*** tbh has quit IRC16:51
*** Vijayendra has quit IRC16:58
*** vishwana_ has joined #tacker16:59
*** vishwanathj has quit IRC17:03
*** abinaya_ has quit IRC17:10
*** abinaya has joined #tacker17:12
*** bobh has joined #tacker17:15
*** lamt has quit IRC17:18
*** mbirru has joined #tacker17:19
*** bobh_ has joined #tacker17:20
*** bobh has quit IRC17:20
*** mike_m has joined #tacker17:34
*** abinaya has quit IRC17:38
*** Vijayendra has joined #tacker17:42
*** bobh_ has quit IRC17:48
*** amotoki has quit IRC17:49
*** abinaya has joined #tacker17:51
sripriyatrozet: ping18:12
*** s3wong has joined #tacker18:15
*** lamt has joined #tacker18:17
*** Vijayendra has quit IRC18:26
*** vishwana_ has quit IRC18:27
*** vishwanathj has joined #tacker18:28
openstackgerritTung Doan proposed openstack/tacker: RFE: Alarm monitor  https://review.openstack.org/38247918:47
*** bobh has joined #tacker18:49
*** tung_doan is now known as tung_doan_afk18:49
*** bobh has quit IRC18:54
trozethi sripriya19:05
sripriyatrozet: hello19:05
sripriyatrozet: i wanted to followup with you on some of vnffg pending items for ocata19:05
sripriyatrozet: i'm grooming some of the topics we want to discuss with networking-sfc team at the summit  and things to followup19:06
trozetsripriya: sure19:07
sripriyatrozet: symmetrical attribute and NSH support is something they are working already and they plan to push it to newton19:08
sripriyatrozet: i' also aware of the new node types you introduced in tacker_nfv_defs.yaml19:09
sripriyatrozet: i suppose these new node types are derived from tosca nfv profile 1.0 right?19:09
trozetsripriya: right19:12
trozetsripriya: it would be nice in ocata to just add the NSD piece, then we can use the real tosca definitions19:12
trozetsripriya: and not use the custom version like we do today19:12
sripriyatrozet: can you please elaborate on the custom version?19:13
trozetsripriya: the custom tosca-parser NFV type for VNFFG19:13
trozetsripriya: from tacker_nfv_defs19:13
sripriyatrozet: okay, these are the tosca data types and FP node type?19:18
trozetsripriya: yeah19:18
trozetsripriya: there is definitely a lot of work to do for next cycle19:18
sripriyatrozet: aren't these types already defined in the tosca nfv profile doc?19:18
trozetsripriya:they are, but becuase we dont use a full NSD, tosca-parser complains19:19
trozetsripriya: remember the 'requirements' part, the requirements need to be in the yaml file :) and the VNFDs, VLs are not there19:19
sripriyatrozet: ah okay, so when say the NSD/real way of implementing, then whatever we have right now as the VNFFGD template changes drastically right?19:23
trozetsripriya: well I was thinking keep VNFFGD like it is, introduce proper NSD19:23
trozetsripriya: then that will also spin up VNFs and create VNFFG19:23
trozetsripriya: we can keep the custom nfv data type now just for VNFFGD backwards compatibility19:24
sripriyatrozet: : okay, i think you are referring to this: http://docs.oasis-open.org/tosca/tosca-nfv/v1.0/tosca-nfv-v1.0.pdf section Using service template for a NFV network service19:25
sripriyatrozet: also, i did not find this referenced int he above link tosca.nfv.datatypes.pathType19:26
sripriyatrozet: nm, figured it19:48
trozetsripriya: i think someone already proposed doing a NSD spec for tacker, their handle started with a 'd'19:49
sripriyatrozet: from some of earlier discussions, we still have things that are not exactly in sync between tosca-translator and nfv profile doc?19:49
sripriyatrozet: /s/tosca-translator/tosca-parser19:50
trozetsripriya: right, like the classifier "policy" does not really match19:50
trozetsripriya: actually its kind of undefined for tosca19:50
sripriyatrozet: yes, dkushwaha has been working on the NSD spec and that has scoped only the VNFD and VNF pieces of NSD19:50
sripriyatrozet: so which one is the right behavior or approach?19:51
trozetsripriya: well I think we need to run the full NSD through the tosca-parser and see what it complains about and then figure out what is the right way19:51
trozetsripriya: we can just do that today19:51
sripriyatrozet: right, i think it will be good to bring this up at the summit with the tosca-parser team19:52
sripriyatrozet: is there any other obvious thing you see which does not match?19:55
trozetsripriya: let me find some time to make a protoype NSD and call tosca-parser and see what it complains about19:55
trozetsripriya: then I can send you an email with what I think/find19:56
sripriyatrozet: that will be very helpful, i will add them to the follow up items19:56
sripriyatrozet: going back to networking-sfc i know supporting VNFFG policies was one thing we identified in last cycle19:57
sripriyatrozet: one for example is scaling19:58
trozetsripriya: yep scaling is a big one.  Also with abstract types, having algorithms for choosing which VNF instance based on load19:58
sripriyatrozet: given that we now support VDU scaling, i think VNFFG scaling will be the next big one19:59
sripriyatrozet: yeah, i think senlin could help with us with implementing load balancing policy and choosing a VNF20:01
*** vishnoianil has quit IRC20:09
sripriyatrozet: just added what we discussed here in https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/tacker-ocata-grooming feel free to edit them and add any missing things20:10
*** openstackgerrit has quit IRC20:19
*** openstackgerrit has joined #tacker20:19
*** vishnoianil has joined #tacker20:24
*** bobh has joined #tacker20:50
*** bobh has quit IRC20:56
*** bobh has joined #tacker21:15
*** bobh has quit IRC22:05
*** abinaya has quit IRC22:28
*** gongysh_ has joined #tacker22:56
gongysh_s3wong, hi, please help me to review some python client patches22:57
*** vishwanathj has quit IRC22:59
*** lamt has quit IRC23:00
gongysh_sripriya, hi23:09
sripriyagongysh_: hello23:09
gongysh_https://review.openstack.org/#/c/313165/6, abour pagination, how about raising a bug to 1. write extra unit cases in python client, 2. write functional cases in tacker server.23:10
gongysh_since those codes are not used at all, let remove them for the time being.23:11
*** igordcard has quit IRC23:14
sripriyagongysh_: responded to your comment, it is no harm retaining this base tests logic in the file23:15
*** igordcard has joined #tacker23:16
*** bobh has joined #tacker23:23
s3wonggongysh_: ack23:25
*** lamt has joined #tacker23:28
openstackgerritgongysh proposed openstack/python-tackerclient: mox to mock refactor  https://review.openstack.org/31316523:34
gongysh_sripriya, I have added a bug and commented those codes23:35
sripriyagongysh_: ack23:39

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.14.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!