Wednesday, 2016-09-21

*** tongli has quit IRC00:02
*** hj-hpe has quit IRC00:44
*** sdake_ has joined #openstack-meeting-cp01:19
*** sdake has quit IRC01:21
*** david-lyle has quit IRC03:04
*** uxdanielle has quit IRC03:19
*** sdake_ has quit IRC03:42
*** markvoelker has quit IRC04:03
*** markvoelker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp04:10
*** Rockyg has quit IRC04:30
*** hemna has joined #openstack-meeting-cp04:46
*** prateek has joined #openstack-meeting-cp05:07
*** markvoelker has quit IRC06:01
*** markvoelker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp06:03
*** markvoelker has quit IRC06:11
*** Rockyg has joined #openstack-meeting-cp06:56
*** markvoelker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp07:11
*** markvoelker has quit IRC07:16
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp09:34
*** sdague has joined #openstack-meeting-cp10:37
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC10:53
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp10:55
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC11:00
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp11:45
*** coolsvap_ is now known as coolsvap12:00
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC12:01
*** markvoelker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp12:33
*** david-lyle has joined #openstack-meeting-cp12:56
*** gouthamr has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:21
*** prateek has quit IRC13:39
*** xyang1 has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:48
*** tongli has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:54
*** lifeless has quit IRC13:57
*** daibz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:58
*** sdake has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:59
*** lifeless has joined #openstack-meeting-cp13:59
*** sdake has quit IRC13:59
*** MarkBaker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:00
*** sdake has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:00
*** kberger has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:00
*** tkfjt has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:00
Rockyghelllooooo14:00
tongli#startmeetingmessage14:01
MarkBakerHi Rockyg14:01
tongliguys, brad will be couple minutes late.14:01
*** lizdurst has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:01
markvoelkero/14:01
tonglican someone try start the meeting. I do not know the command.14:01
markvoelker#startmeeting Interop Challenge14:02
openstackmarkvoelker: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.14:02
markvoelkerhah, already in progress14:02
tonglioh, ok.14:02
tonglio/14:02
kencjohnstono/14:02
luzCo/14:02
lizdursto/14:02
MarkBaker\o14:02
Rockyghey MarkBaker14:02
tonglihow can we get to the action items?14:03
*** rarcea has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:03
*** leong has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:03
Rockygpost link to etherpad...14:03
leongo/14:04
tongliah.14:04
tonglibrad asked me to start review the action items.14:04
rarceao/14:04
tongliso let's see, JASON__, Rockyg to check on DT cloud.14:04
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:04
*** irena has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:05
tonglithat is action #1, do we have Jason ?14:05
eeideno/14:05
Rockygdang.  don't see jason on line.14:05
tongli@Rockyg, any update on that and Huawei cloud?14:05
RockygI can give you staus from others :-/14:06
*** igormarnat_ has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:06
markvoelker#link https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/interop-challenge-meeting-2016-09-21 < today's etherpad for those who don't have it14:06
tongli@Rockyg, I was looking for him last night and could not reach him.14:06
Rockygno idea about huawei status14:06
tongli@Rockyg, please update if you have some.14:06
tonglion DT?14:07
Rockygnope.14:07
*** Tetsuo_ has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:07
*** ativelkov has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:07
topolHello14:07
* topol better late than never14:07
topolsorry for ebing late14:07
Rockygand another China holiday starting next week...14:07
*** vkmc has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:08
vkmco/14:08
tonglibrad, we were just talking about the DT and Huawei account, and we do not have them available yet.14:08
tonglithat is the first action item from last week.14:08
topolK, thanks tongli14:08
Rockygno progress :-(14:08
tongliyou can take over.14:08
* topol wondering how we have no gas in raleigh yet still a traffic jam :-)14:09
topolwill do14:09
topol#topic review action items from previous meeting14:09
topol#link http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/interop_challenge/2016/interop_challenge.2016-09-14-14.00.html14:09
topolSo no word yet on Huaweii or DT, correct?14:09
Rockygcorrect14:10
MarkBakerDT = Deutsche Telekom?14:10
topolHopefully we can get them running soon.  tongli is eager to help14:10
topolMarkBaker yes!14:10
MarkBakerI guess the DT Open Telco cloud14:10
topolMarkBaker exactly14:11
MarkBakervery cool14:11
topolso lets keep those action items:14:11
topol#action JASON__, Rockyg to check on DT cloud14:11
topol#action JASON__, Rockyg to check on Huaweii cloud as well14:11
topolK, next item14:11
topolplease figure out who is the right executive in your company that is supposed to handle quotes for the press. We will need to have PR folks contact them and will need to move quickly on that. Check with your OpenStack Board member rep.14:12
topolSo are folks looking into this?14:12
*** osh has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:12
*** zhurong has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:12
topolplease email the proper contacts if you have them. I will be reahing out to folks in personal emails this week14:12
MarkBakertopol, email to you?14:12
topolyes, you can send me the contacts by email. I will also email who we had listed as main contacts for each company this week as well14:13
markvoelkertopol: also, could you give folks some idea of what the ask is?  E.g. are you looking on-camera interviews in Barcelona, or a written quote or two, or...?14:13
topolI expect these will be written quotes14:14
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC14:14
markvoelkerok, thanks14:14
topolmarkvoelker, sure NP14:14
topolIm gonna hit this topic again later in the meeting as well14:14
topolnext item, luzC to see if we can get reviews speeded up14:14
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:15
topolI know tongli big patch merged so this is better correct? Or at least no show stopping?14:15
topolnot showstopping14:15
luzCyes I chatted with Joseph Bajin14:15
tongli@topol, that is correct. latest is in.14:15
*** hj-hpe has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:15
topolexcellent.14:15
topolSo latest is in and it has been updated from lessons learned from various clouds.14:16
luzChe suggested to ask on the channel or look for the cores directly, he is a core and he can help with the +2 once the patches are reviewed(in depth)14:16
luzCchannel:  ##openstack-operators14:16
* markvoelker is planning to run this on some of our new Mitaka-based clouds this week14:17
luzClist of cores: https://review.openstack.org/#/admin/groups/1076,members14:17
topolluzC very nice! Thank you14:17
*** kzaitsev_ws has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:17
tongli@markvoelker, that is great. eager to hear the results.14:18
topolso next item.  all try and run both terraform and ansible of docker swarm14:18
topolIs anyone close to running this that hasnt already reported back?14:18
topolDoes anyone need help from tongli?14:18
tongli@vkmc, you have any updates? I know you were running yesterday?14:18
vkmctongli, unfortunately I hit some networking issues in my environment... I'm debugging that14:19
tongliA DreamHost guy sent out an email announcing the successful run on their cloud.14:19
vkmcas soon as I have some results I'll update you all14:19
vkmcthanks!14:19
topolvkmc, Thanks. Let us know.14:19
tonglionly lampstack though, he also sent out the link to see the results.14:20
tonglihttp://208.113.133.137/14:20
luzCtopol I run the workloads, refstack this week... I'll send the results this week...14:20
tongliif anyone wants to see the results.14:20
topoltongli,  thats really good to know. LAMPStack is the one we will highlight in Barcelona. Its the one the foundation likes best14:20
luzCI was waiting a little on the NFV one...14:21
topoldo we know who the person from DreamHost was?  We need to get connected to them14:21
tongli@topol,yes14:21
MarkBakertopol, tongli we'll be running the Heat/Terraform setup tests against Mitaka and Newton sometime the first week of Oct.14:21
topolluzC  funny you mention that.  So a little heart to heart...14:22
*** sslypushenko has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:22
markvoelkertopol: Stefano Maffulli IIRC14:22
tongliyea.14:22
topolOctober is gonna sneak up on us real fast.14:22
tonglinot sure if he has run refstack or docker one.14:22
topolWhile this interop challenge will live on after October and we will continue to make progress, at the Summit we need to showcase accomplishments and put our best foot forward14:23
tongliHe also sent out a long email about this effort and has quite few questions.14:23
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:24
topolSo for October everyone should all be focused on the same goal of getting LAMPStack running.  That will be for sure the one the foundation wants us to demo14:24
topolI personally will breathe a lot easier when folks come back saying, "Hey we got this workload successfully running"14:25
topolso please folks make that workload the priority.14:25
topolany concerns?14:25
*** aimeeu__ has quit IRC14:26
topolnext item:14:27
topoltong and brad to ask eglute about running on RAX public and security group support14:27
topolSo tongli and myself have been working with folks to try and get things running on RAX public.  I think we are hitting issues with security group support.14:28
topoltongli am I correct?14:28
tongli@topol, yes.14:28
topoleglute and others we continue to work that14:29
tonglithe security group supported by RAX has to be managed by their own APIs.14:29
tonglinot standard OS api,14:29
tongliI wonder if we have RAX guy in this conversation.14:29
kencjohnstonI'm here :)14:29
topolhey, cool its kencjohnston14:30
tongli@kencjohnston, is my understanding of the security group correct?14:30
tongliI mean on RAX public cloud.14:30
kencjohnstonI'm happy to help work through any issues, but unfortunately I'm not a RAX Public Cloud expert.14:30
kencjohnstonI think we had an email thread going on the topic, want to revive it with the current issues?14:31
topolso kencjohnston,  we'll keep working with whatever SME you  provide us :-)14:31
topolsure14:31
kencjohnstonWe also have a pretty awesome support team...14:31
topolkencjohnston yes you do14:31
topol#action tongli and topol to provde kencjohnston and update via email14:31
kencjohnstonThat's to say, let's not let me be the bottleneck here.14:32
topolyep, sounds good14:32
topolso todays agenda...14:32
topolpretty much similar to last weeks action items14:32
topol#topic Status Check:  When will folks be sending in results14:33
tongli@topol, I think we need sort of confirmation which cloud we can use for the on-stage demo at ODS.14:33
topoltongli, first lets get a list of everyone who can successfully run LAMPStack and on what cloud they have14:34
tonglik14:34
topolfrom that list the foundation will help us with guidance.14:34
topolso where should we put this list so its easily accessible?14:35
*** rohit404 has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:35
topolwiki page?14:35
topolany concerns with putting this on the wiki page?14:35
* topol markvoelker usually has good advice on things like this14:36
markvoelkerwiki sounds fine to me14:36
vkmc+114:36
luzCthe list of participants is already on the wiki... there is a status column14:36
topolluzC, great point!!!14:36
Rockygias long as you have posted to the wiki before, you'r fine.  Otherwise, you'll neeed to get help to gt an account from infra14:37
rarcea+114:37
anteayaso you know this is not being logged as a meeting14:37
anteayaif you check the channel topic14:37
anteayathe startmeeting comand needs one whitespace between the command and the name of the meeting14:37
anteayafor next time14:37
topol#startmeeting interop_challenge14:38
openstacktopol: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.14:38
topol#endmeeting14:38
topol#startmeeting interop_challenge14:38
openstacktopol: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.14:38
topolI dont seem to be able to do endmeeting14:38
anteayacan tongli end it?14:38
tongli#endmeeting14:39
*** openstack changes topic to "OpenStack Meetings || https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Meetings"14:39
anteayathere we go14:39
topolthis is my fault. I gave tongli bad instructions on how to start the meeting when I was stuck in traffic14:39
topol#startmeeting interop_challenge14:39
openstacktopol: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress.  Use #endmeeting first.14:39
anteayatopol you should be good14:39
RockygSo, we had a mting.  Just a very weird title.14:39
anteayaapparently14:39
anteayanot sure what is wrong now, sorry to interrupt14:39
anteayathe -cp channel is logged anyway14:40
anteayaafter you finish I'll see if I can unravel this14:40
topolok14:40
anteayasorry14:40
topolwell lets proceed14:40
topolanteaya thanks14:40
anteayawelcome14:40
topol#action all update the wiki with your results on which cloud you could successfully run LAMPStack14:41
topol#action tongli lets get a wiki entry for dreamhost14:42
tonglishould the references be a link?14:42
*** osh has quit IRC14:42
topollinks are good to have for all the details and should be there. But I want a summary right on the wiki page as well14:43
topolso folks can quickly see where the workload is running and the contact person14:43
*** lizdurst has quit IRC14:44
tongli@topol, I have just added dreamhost to the list.14:44
topolOff the top of my head we run on BlueBox, OSIC, OVH, markvoelkers vmware cloud (what do we call that?) and dreamhost14:44
topoldid I miss anyone?14:44
tongli@topol, that is about right.14:45
topolhopefully Cisco, Huaweii, and DT cloud are soon14:45
tongliwho is from Hitachi?14:45
topolany idea about Red Hat, Suse, Canonical, HItachi?14:45
tongliNetApp?14:45
topolor NetApp :-)14:45
tongliNot sure who put NetApp in the list if we do not have rep.14:46
topol#action topol to reachout by email to folks to check on status14:46
RockygAnne Gentle trid it on Cisco cloud.  Tongli might try conncting with her...14:46
topoltongli, I have netAPP contacts14:46
*** rohit404 has quit IRC14:46
tonglik.14:46
topolso the other related topics14:47
topol#topic for press quotes14:47
topolalready mentioned. email me these14:48
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC14:48
topol#topic contacts to be on stage (if asked)14:48
topolif asked to be on stage by the foundation, who will be available to come up under the bright lights14:49
topolplease let me know14:49
topolthis has been a great effort so lets get some folks on a stage hopefully :-)14:49
*** bryan_att has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:49
topol#action all Get LAMPStack running,  free signed Keystone Book from topol if you do14:50
rarcearegarding above, for SUSE, will try to get results in a week or so14:50
topolrarcea AWESOME14:50
rarceaprobably more realistic first week of october14:51
MarkBakertopol, we (canonical) will get this running before BCN14:51
irenayes, re on stage. luz and i will bring up with OSIC team at Intel. brad, can you or johanna send email with any initial messaging ideas and partner involvement and we will help get the right people on board.14:51
*** zhurong has quit IRC14:51
topolirena, yes those emails will go out soon14:51
bryan_atttopol: hi it's Bryan from AT&T - been working with Elise to get you a VNF for the challenge. Just want to be sure the ask is clear, so we target the right complexity level.14:51
topolMarkBaker awesome!14:52
bryan_atttopol: if you have a wiki page with details a link is fine14:52
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:52
tongli@rarcea, you have two version of OS to run against?14:52
rarceatongli: yes. We will try to get both, worst case probably just Newton14:53
*** irena_ has joined #openstack-meeting-cp14:53
MarkBakertopol, we aim to get Juju deploying workloads across other OpenStack clouds too - if successful we'll be able to demo an NFV workload14:53
topolbryan_att  I have tobe honest.  Im scared there is not enough runway for NFV to be showcased in Barcelona.  The foundation loves the LAMPStack so you should get that one working first14:53
topolbryan_att NFV may be our post Barcelona work item14:53
Rockygalso quick update... DT is closer.  Probably some rsults this week.14:53
bryan_atttopol: a basic LAMP stack is easy. But what makes it an NFV workload is the question, vs a plain cloud-based web service.14:54
MarkBakerbryan_att, we are targeting an IMS or EPC14:54
bryan_attMarkBaker: OPNFV has vIMS ready to go but it has significant resource requirements.14:54
topolbryan_att The LAMP stack was highlighted because of its enterprise characteristics.  It has a load balancer, multiple nodes, security groups, etc14:54
tongliand database node, volumes as well.14:55
bryan_atttopol: OK, those expectations would be good to clarify so we don't make it too simple ;-)14:55
tongliit basically pulls most of the elements of cloud together to make things happen.14:55
*** irena has quit IRC14:55
topolbryan_att the security groups have been trick from an interop perspective14:55
topolbryan_att do you have the LAMPStack workload successfully running?14:56
bryan_atttopol: not a specific one, with a specific config.14:56
bryan_atttopol: I can work on a concept though but as you say Barcelona would be a stretch.14:56
vkmc<topol> any idea about Red Hat, Suse, Canonical, HItachi? <- I'm running for Red Hat :)14:56
vkmcs/for/on/g14:57
topolbryan_att, you should be able to use the standard one we have provided that uses ansible14:57
topolvkmc excelelnt14:57
tongli@bryan_att, if you run the easy one first and get some results, that will be nice.14:57
topolbryan_att tongli can help you to run the standard one we have14:57
bryan_atttopol: is that standard one linked somewhere - I will look into it14:57
bryan_atttopol: and in the process look at the security group issues14:58
topoltongli please connect with bryan_att and get him all the details14:58
tonglihttps://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib/tree/master/ansible14:58
tonglithey are there.14:58
bryan_attthanks, let me go look and try it out14:58
MarkBakerbryan_att, we will likely test initially with Metaswitch14:58
tongliclone and follow the README instructions. easy.14:58
topol#link https://github.com/openstack/osops-tools-contrib/tree/master/ansible14:58
*** openstack has joined #openstack-meeting-cp15:00
*** ChanServ sets mode: +o openstack15:00
anteayawe'll try15:00
topolthanks15:00
tongli@topol, sorry about that.15:00
anteayaif all else fails the channel is logged15:01
topolmy fault15:01
anteayatongli: it is a fault of the bot, it shouldn't have done what it did15:01
anteayanot your fault15:01
topolblame the bot :-)15:01
fungitongli: topol: i think it's probably a legitimate bug in the meetbot we didn't know about until you found it ;)15:01
RockygYup, and we can link to the log and put in th time stamps15:01
tongli@anteaya, @topol. thanks guys.15:01
topolthanks everyone15:01
anteayathe log is here: http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/irclogs/%23openstack-meeting-cp/%23openstack-meeting-cp.2016-09-21.log.html15:01
tongli@Rockgy, thanks for fixing it.15:01
vkmcthanks :)15:01
anteayajust no minutes15:01
Rockygthanks, anteaya15:02
tongli@vkmc, let me know if you need help.15:02
vkmctongli, will do15:02
anteayathank you15:02
vkmcthanks for that15:02
topolill update the wiki page with action items manually15:03
anteayatopol: thanks15:04
*** leong has quit IRC15:06
*** Tetsuo_ has quit IRC15:11
*** tkfjt has quit IRC15:11
*** hemna_ has joined #openstack-meeting-cp15:41
*** hemna_ has quit IRC15:41
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC15:46
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp15:48
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC15:55
*** mkarpiarz has joined #openstack-meeting-cp15:57
*** Guest26157 is now known as cFouts16:00
*** mkarpiarz has quit IRC16:01
*** uxdanielle has joined #openstack-meeting-cp16:02
*** ebalduf has joined #openstack-meeting-cp16:06
*** daibz has quit IRC16:09
*** vkmc is now known as vkmc|afk16:14
*** vkmc|afk is now known as vkmc18:12
*** rosmaita has joined #openstack-meeting-cp18:25
*** gouthamr has quit IRC18:31
*** sdake has quit IRC18:39
*** gouthamr has joined #openstack-meeting-cp18:51
*** sdake has joined #openstack-meeting-cp18:56
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC19:44
*** kzaitsev_mb has joined #openstack-meeting-cp19:46
*** prateek has quit IRC20:03
*** coolsvap has quit IRC20:42
*** uxdanielle has quit IRC20:55
*** tongli has quit IRC21:00
*** gouthamr has quit IRC21:34
*** melwitt has left #openstack-meeting-cp21:42
*** melwitt has joined #openstack-meeting-cp21:42
*** ebalduf has quit IRC22:01
*** xyang1 has quit IRC22:22
*** markvoelker has quit IRC22:43
*** rarcea has quit IRC22:47
*** sdague has quit IRC23:00
*** kzaitsev_mb has quit IRC23:23
*** markvoelker has joined #openstack-meeting-cp23:44
*** zhurong has joined #openstack-meeting-cp23:47
*** markvoelker has quit IRC23:49
*** gouthamr has joined #openstack-meeting-cp23:52
*** zhurong has quit IRC23:57

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.14.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!